PDS Clarification

  • nazimwildfire
  • nazimwildfire's Avatar Topic Author
  • Offline
  • New Member
  • New Member
More
16 years 7 months ago - 16 years 7 months ago #8750 by nazimwildfire
PDS Clarification was created by nazimwildfire
I am A Plant Design Engg for 3 years,
I have been in PDS, I have taken care of Areas by my own.

But I dnt Think I am Doing wat a Plant Design Engg has to do, I dont have a clear picture to were I should start.

All I know about piping is upto what I worked and got from Exp.

I see People here haveing superiour knowledge and The questions are like I can never even think about these stuff.

Please help me out. I know its gono be a long road to walk but I am ready for it, Please guide me to what topics I have to go through or study.

Thank you.
Nazim.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
16 years 7 months ago - 16 years 7 months ago #4181 by Jop
Replied by Jop on topic Nazim, First of all you are
Nazim,
First of all you are Not, I repeat not, a Plant design engineer. You are also Not a Piping design engineer.
It would appear to me that you are an accidental drafting novice. You are not even an accidental “piping” draftsman because you have had (by your own admission) no formal piping training. It scares me a great deal that people in your country, with no formal piping training are allowed to do piping work of any kind. At this point you do not know what you do not know. By your own admission you do not know very much. If you are allowed to continue to work on the design of piping systems, someday you (or someone like you) will do something very wrong. This wrong is going to get plant operators or maintenance workers injured or killed.

Two months ago you wrote and said you had been doing piping for one and a half years. Now you say that you have been doing piping for three years. I don’t know how you get another year and a half’s worth of experience in two months. At that time I told you to check out the training section of this web site. It is obvious that you have not done that.

When you do check the training section you will only get some of the most basic information about pipe, valves, fittings and flanges along with some information about stress, vessels and pipe shops and the field. There is more information under the Tips and Standards buttons. You need to make a print of everything you find and start your own Training Manual.

You should also look in the Technical Forum and look up the subject of Training Books. You (and others) should get together and buy some of these books. If there are ten people and each one of you buys just one book then you will have ten technical books about piping. Start your own library of technical books.

Some how, some way you must get some proper training. If you don’t, then you will always be a danger to the people who work in the finished plants.

Do it once and Do it Right

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • nazimwildfire
  • nazimwildfire's Avatar Topic Author
  • Offline
  • New Member
  • New Member
More
16 years 7 months ago - 16 years 7 months ago #4182 by nazimwildfire
Replied by nazimwildfire on topic thank you
I will go through the training manual this time thank you.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Buggernuts
  • Buggernuts's Avatar
  • Visitor
  • Visitor
16 years 7 months ago - 16 years 7 months ago #4183 by Buggernuts
Replied by Buggernuts on topic Jop, EXCELLENT reply!!!!! You are right, one
Jop,

EXCELLENT reply!!!!!

You are right, one day there is going to be one almighty accident as a result of these guys who have 'Done' PDS or PDMS. Its not a game boy or an XBox!! If you dont have the basic design skills and training you should not in my opinion, be let anywhere near a live Project!!

When I started out in the world of Contracting, every interview I attended I was given a small 'task' to do, either on a CAD station or on paper, OK, so it wasnt perfect, but at least the prospective employer could see you had the background.

Does that happen these days???? Errm.... No!!!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
16 years 7 months ago - 16 years 7 months ago #4184 by 11echo
Replied by 11echo on topic You know this whole situation
You know this whole situation stems from decisions made back in the early to mid-80’s. Somewhere in the big company “think tanks” they came up with the idea that they could layoff all the older engineers and just keep the younger engineers …after all they can push around the numbers just as well as the “older (more expensive) types” can! …They’d keep one or two of the older guys to ride herd on the younger ones. Then, unfortunately, they focused on the design/drafting group! Why keep a dept. of these people when you can farm out any projects as needed.
Also at this time (I’m thinking Murphy’s Law here) AutoCAD poked its ugly head up! Now in a profession where standards and convention was the rule, AutoCAD was like the torpedo that sunk that ship! It now becomes more “important” to know how to run a computer program then it did on how to do a design or to document a design! AND to complicate matters a number of older designers/draftsmen decided to retire early rather than to have to learn a whole new way of doing things!
…So things plugged along, and this system was “working” …project were not that large, and construction could “fudge” things to get the system in and working. It has fumbled along in this manner for about 10 plus years now. …BUT now things are different! Major projects are looming and with the attrition rate of the last decade the design/drafting group number & capabilities are lacking! Yes we have a number of “CAD jockeys” around. They can run all the programs with out any problems! …EXCEPT they don’t have any idea how to a design, or what do to make a “proper” drawing! So what you have now are “young engineers” that make red line mark ups that are passed to CAD jockeys who put them in a drawing VERBATUM, and call it good! Engineers are not draftsmen! And most are not close to being designers either! They’ve never learned (from older guys) how things are done or what they are supposed to look like! And trying to do it now is like explaining what the color red looks like to a blind person! …I face this problem daily!
AND that “think tank” that has help make this situation, has come up with the new idea to farm the engineering/design/drafting out to third world nations that would gladly work for pennies on the dollars! It all makes sense …letting people do the job for a price that is much less then what it would cost else where! …Good economics thinking!!! …EXCEPT the people that “think” they can do the job CAN’T! …And the people that should know DON”T! It’s as simple as that! …AND this is not going to change …no matter what the computer program salesman tells you!!!
Sorry to highjack this thread, but I needed to publicly “VENT”! …And again these are my own ranting & ravings! …Mark

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
16 years 7 months ago - 16 years 7 months ago #4185 by Jop
Replied by Jop on topic You have no need to
You have no need to apologize. Your comments are oh so true.

Do it once and Do it Right

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: Jop
Time to create page: 0.235 seconds