PipingDesigners Community

A place for piping designers, engineers and industry professionals to ask questions, share experience, discuss technical topics and connect with other professionals.

Browse the discussions below or start a new topic. Please keep discussions practical, professional and relevant to the piping and engineering community.

all Should Pump Fla...
 
Notifications
Clear all

all Should Pump Flanged Nozzle rating should MATCH( strictly) with the rating of Flange of connecting pipe to that…

11 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
59 Views
(@skgarg)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 91
Topic starter   [#304]

hi all
Should Pump Flanged Nozzle rating should MATCH( strictly) with the rating of Flange of connecting pipe to that nozzle ?
I mean suppose if the suction nozzle of Boiler Feed Pump is ( ASME CLASS 300 RF)
then the connecting flange ( Piping scope) should be of same rating (ASME CLASS 300 RF) NO MORE NO LESS
Regards
SG



   
Quote
(@2ndmoment)
Eminent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 29
 

Yes and No.

Yes, from the obvious, geometric perspective that using another rating lower or higher may provide dimensional mismatch viz. dissimilar bolts, different PCD and so on. The gasket should invariably remain the same though.

No, from the engineering perspective; whereby the pump flange is rated for the highest pressure that the pump may be expected to deliver. Bear in mind that in the case of a multistage, centrifugal pump - not unlike a BFP - the standard castings of a pump would need to cater for the worst case or maximum number of additional, sandwiched stages which the manufacturer markets for a specific model of pump. Equipment manufacturers may also elect to “beef” up their nozzle flanges i.e. providing a higher rating in order to provide greater resistance to assembly misalignment.

The designer would still need to match the pipe flange to that of the pump (or any other equipment). But because the pump may not necessarily be delivering its maximum head or the process group has not rated the system as high as the pump flange can take, the designer would still rely on the piping material specification for guidance on flanges. This why in particular cases the piping specification may even provide for two different flange classes, example #150 and #300. Generally this apparent ambiguity indicates that the system is congruent with #150 (all pipe flange to pipe flange joints) but #300 may be used for dimensional reasons to bolt up to process equipment.

Another point to consider: eventhough you have indicated that you are dealing with a RF interface, many pumps - particluary for low pressure water distribution use FF. In this case regardless of the class of flange the designer should still allow for FF to FF. Using a RF to FF creates a) indue bending stresses in the flange of the cast pump and b) reduces the sealing capacity of a gasket.

2M



   
ReplyQuote
(@skgarg)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 91
Topic starter  

Hi 2M
Agreed with your answer "YES"
in Case of critical areas like BFP i think they should STRICTLY match.
but couldn't decipher the meaning of "NO".
one linked Question Piping material class is decided after Pump selection or prior to that or Parallel?
Regards
SG



   
ReplyQuote
(@2ndmoment)
Eminent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 29
 

SG,

Let me, perhaps, adjust the “No” portion. Instead of “No” rather interpret as “not always”. Nonetheless, whether the stronger flange is required from an engineering perspective or not is academic as the geometric interfacing is paramount – a no brainer if you will.

To address the linked question: the selection process is aligned with standard process plant design workflow. I would recommend James O Pennock’s Piping Engineering Leadership – referring in particular to Chapter 2. The material class must be matched to the information received from a) the design group (whether mechanical or process) responsible for the hydraulic system calculation data which will highlight the operating (and upset) pressures and temperatures and b) the information received from the design group responsible for the obtaining or certifying equipment data.

In the specific case of a single stage, centrifugal pump model, the operating and shut-off pressures (heads) are dependent on the chosen diameter and speed of the impeller. A smaller impeller running at a lower speed will provide a lower head than that of the converse – for the same pump model. BUT, that same model of pump will have a casing and flange rated for the largest impeller running at the highest speed. The piping class need not match the maximum that the pump could push out (largest & highest); merely including an exception for physical bolting up.



   
ReplyQuote
 hc
(@hc)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 96
 

simple answer for no......the mating flange will need to match the pump nozzle in all cases but, the engineer may spec out a bigger pump based on a worst case situation but only requires lower pressure piping under normal conditions. So for example you may have a 600# pump nozzle but your piping may be only 300# piping. Depending on your arrangement somewhere you will have a spec break. I hope that helps.



   
ReplyQuote
(@11echo)
Reputable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 332
 

In response to the original question …in general I would say yes! …BUT in certain situations, I’d say no! The certain situation I’m thinking of involves cast iron pumps where the suction & discharge flange rating is either 125# or 250# both Flat Faced. Now normally this pump is piped up with a steel spec. piping system. So you’d have to use 150# on the 125# or 300# on the 250# …flange diameter, bolt size, quantity, & location are the same in these ratings (125#/150# & 250#/300#) …but as 2M pointed out the cast iron rating is in Flat Face only, so the Raised Face on the steel flanges have to be machined off to the FF configuration.



   
ReplyQuote
(@harshalpbhanej)
Active Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 8
 

"Should Pump Flanged Nozzle rating should MATCH( strictly) with the rating of Flange of connecting pipe to that nozzle? "

I will say we have to select same class flange only for piping design.
For example if Dischange nozzle of pump is 300# and piping pressure is in acceptable limits of 150# then also we have to connect 300# flange. (not talking about piping only flange)

you always can ask one class higher rating flange in your spec. If you check it will be there already...(perhaps) If not...u can ask for.
but dont go in the loop that weather you can use dissimmilar rating flange or not?

one point that 11eacho has raised.
I want to tell something more on that.
Most of the Manufacturers always do production of RF flanges only. If they got order of FF flanges.
They can do it anytime. (they just have to machine the raised face)



   
ReplyQuote
(@shrivallabha)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 134
 

Hi 2M
Agreed with your answer "YES"
in Case of critical areas like BFP i think they should STRICTLY match.
but couldn't decipher the meaning of "NO".
one linked Question Piping material class is decided after Pump selection or prior to that or Parallel?
Regards
SG

SG,

Process Design department works out Mass flow rate, Pressure Temperature Conditions, Fluid Velocity. In short, design data. The pump selection (beginning from the type i.e. centrifugal or PD etc.) depends on this design data. So the pump selection, does not depend on the Piping Material Class directly (as to rating).

The Piping Material Class is again great example of common sense and standardisation. Piping Material Class is interpretation of P-T Design Data and that is why you will see that Piping Material Classes serves a 'range' of design pressures and temperatures. Imagine a situation if we had to design piping commodities for each of the P-T condition. That is why for so many P-T conditions, us pipers use a few ratings.

Now to the matching classes part, this might be governed by the situation:
For class 900 and 1500, flanges are dimensionally same up to 2 inch. So when you need flanges in #900 rating class and if #1500 are in the warehouse then 'tis better to use them than ordering new ones.

Materials people will also do this with gaskets (#300 and #600), all gaskets would be #600.

No one will mind Overdesign as long as it is not creating financial Overload!



   
ReplyQuote
 hc
(@hc)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 96
 

Jop you are correct. That was sort of what I was trying to say. A question should be the end result in both cases to find out if there's a bigger design issue........just in case.
The big lesson here is that this is unusual and you never, ever, ever assume because you can make it work that it's correct. Engineers make mistakes, Senior Designers make mistakes, PM's make mistakes and no body explodes if they ask a question. The answer may be simple or something may be wrong. You need to know why it's unusual. Hopefully that makes sense.

Now Jop if you wouldn't mind could you please find a way to pipe some warm air up from Florida to Nova Scotia around January 1st thru to March 21st, to make our winter feel more like our fall I'd be very happy. I'm not looking for hot.....50 degrees would be perfect.



   
ReplyQuote
 hc
(@hc)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 96
 

Just a thought......

We spent time in this thread and many others trying to estimate why there may be a spec/rating break at the pump flanges. It's great that some have the knowledge to sound like an engineer and get all technical. The truth is that someone like me goes blah, blah, blah....poser and then tries to write a post simple enough that someone can understand. Rather than trying to pull a "reason why" out of our arse on a situation we have no background on. I think it's really important we focus on helping someone know what their options are in respects to the piping design and help them put together good questions that they can ask their project teams? As a senior, I don't pretend to know anything other than what I know...I ask questions. I also never assume, someone's right because they can pull the engineer or experience card on me. Stop getting all technical and treat every post as if they're talking to a junior Piper. That's my thought of the day.



   
ReplyQuote
(@bhaveshkh)
New Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 3
 

The simple answer to this query is 'Yes' the companion mating flange should be of same rating as that of the pump flange. As the PCD of the any other flange will not match.

This is the reason sometimes we ask for mating companion flange from the pumpo vendor who is suppling flanges from other codes like DIN or 125pound rating which will not be as per our piping classes and is worth buying from the pump vendor.

Regards

Bhavesh



   
ReplyQuote
Share: