PipingDesigners Community

A place for piping designers, engineers and industry professionals to ask questions, share experience, discuss technical topics and connect with other professionals.

Browse the discussions below or start a new topic. Please keep discussions practical, professional and relevant to the piping and engineering community.

Friends, Is there a...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Friends, Is there any apparent disadvantages in welding a valve to a valve?

12 Posts
4 Users
0 Reactions
121 Views
(@banerj1s)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 65
Topic starter   [#88]

Friends,

Is there any apparent disadvantages in welding a valve to a valve? Due to extreme shortages of spaces specially near the condenser in a power plant the stop valve and the quick closing check valves are welded to each other in some of my earlier projects.
I would appreciate any expert comments on this.

Regards
Sudipto



   
Quote
(@jop)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1164
 

If we think about this logically we should have an answer.

In piping you can normally weld any one object to any other object with no problem as long as there is no interference caused by something in or on the two objects.

That means that you can weld:
- Pipe to pipe
- Pipe to flange
- Flange to flange
- Fitting to fitting
- Fitting to pipe
- Fitting to flange
- Fitting to butt weld valve
- Pipe to butt weld valve
- Flange to a butt weld valve
And since these are "Butt Weld" valves, you can weld on the valve body.

So, if there is no interference caused by one or more of the valves internals or top-works then you should be able to weld them valve to valve.



   
ReplyQuote
(@banerj1s)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 65
Topic starter  

Thanks Jop. I didnt get many to agree on this because they think that it would be impossible to retrieve the valves at a later stage because they have to cut the valve in case of maintenance. But my experience says that big valves of 20" steam service should not develop problem on the valve body for at least 15 years. Even if they do valves are rarely cut. The welding is done at the spot itself.
The quick closing valves are swing check and it is followed by a gate valve. So no clash of internals are expected.
Hope for your comments on this.

Cheers
Sudipto



   
ReplyQuote
(@raghurambathula)
Active Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 9
 

take care of soft internals which may be damaged due to heat generated during welding



   
ReplyQuote
(@11echo)
Reputable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 332
 

Hmmm ...so you’re fighting space and still need a block valve with a check? Could you use a "stop check valve"? This valve is a combination of both, where you can get a bubble tight closure like a globe valve, but with a piston type check valve. I've used them afew times where we were looking to save money but have both capabilities. The only question would be "if" the piston type check valve would quick acting enough for you? Here's a link for a look see:
http://www.tpub.com/content/constructio ... 65_126.htm



   
ReplyQuote
(@banerj1s)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 65
Topic starter  

Thanks for the post 11echo. I really thought about it for long. But lets understand the operation here. The stop valve is actually to isolate the heaters from the Turbine in case of Heater Failure or turbine trip on the Steam water cycle of a power plant. The check valve would prevent any backflow of the water back to the Turbine and has to close within a split of a sec or risking severe water damage to the Turbine. I am not sure if a stop check valve can also be a quick closing valve operating at high temperature and pressure working on a steam sytem. As far as I know they are manual valves and some projects they are used in HVAC.



   
ReplyQuote
(@11echo)
Reputable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 332
 

banerj1s ...As I said I've only used these type valves a few times, once in a 600# hydrocarbon service as a block valve. And once in a 600# feedwater line. Essentially they are a globe valve with the stem disconnected from the gate/piston ...so I would suspect they could be used anywhere a globe valve could be used. Now I'm guessing at this point there are 2 issues, for your use. You require a "quick acting" check valve. A piston check valve is a "non-slam" type check valve so I'm not sure this "check valve" will be suitable in the "quick acting" role(maybe JOP could wade in with his infinite wisdom on this?). The other issue would be a stop check valve is alittle on the "odd-ball" side, so trying to locate one for your application "could" be difficult and costly ...but again I'm not sure one this. HOWEVER for your initial problem this would be a GREAT fix! My $0.02 anyway. Good Luck my Friend!



   
ReplyQuote
(@jop)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1164
 

11echo's suggestion for the potential use of a (duel-function) "Stop Check" valve is valid. This type of valve has been used widely in power plants and steam plants.
The problem I have is we do not know where you are or where your job site is. We to not know your logistical or schedule constraints. We also do not know the details about the specific steam line. Details such as line size, rating, material, design pressure, temperature and configuration.

Of course, maybe all of this is not important to the original question.



   
ReplyQuote
(@banerj1s)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 65
Topic starter  

Line size is 10" Design Temperature is 820 deg F and it is 300# class spec carbon steel. It is actually very much relevant to the intent of the original question because in case of a stop check valve the condition wont arise of a stop valve and a piston assisted check valve being placed together.
Thanks for the information Jop. Please can you confirm if you have used stop check valves on steam systems also?



   
ReplyQuote
(@jop)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1164
 

Yes I have used them, but it was a long time ago.



   
ReplyQuote
(@11echo)
Reputable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 332
 

Now there's one more issue I need to list here about this "stop check valve". IF you came upon this valve "cold turkey"(not knowing anything about it) you'd be hard pressed to know it was a check valve! First look you’d swear it was just a globe valve. Now this particular issue may or may not be a problem for you and your company, and the way around it would be to have good documentation and a particular symbol for a stop check valve. This doesn't always happen in my neck of the woods. So your people will need that information for any future interaction.
Here's a link for a "Petro" stop check valve that could probably cover your need, you'll have to verify that. Again Good luck!

http://www.petrovalve.com/products_type ... k%20Valves

Honey ...They are called "Engineers", normally a pain in the kester, but for that application they do a good job! *G* ...Everybody have a GOOD DAY! ...Mark



   
ReplyQuote
(@jop)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1164
 

Honey,
I think 11echo means "Process Engineer"



   
ReplyQuote
Share: